For travelers on a budget or in a group, self-guided scavenger hunts offer the lowest cost, with the Holiday Scavenger Hunt covering up to 10 people for $15. However, the Fort Collins' Old Town and River District city game, also priced per group, has mixed reviews: one guest received no support or access link, calling it 'extremely badly organized.'
Walking tours are the backbone of the catalogue, priced from $21 to $38 per person. The best-reviewed are led by knowledgeable guides who focus on local history, nature, or ghost stories. The Fort Collins Ghost Tour stands out with 4.70 from 50 reviews and includes access to unique underground sites. Some guests with mobility issues found the ghost tour challenging, citing stairs and basements, and a few felt the tour was more historical than haunted. The Haunted Pub Tour, also $21, is praised for its stories but criticized by some for requiring drink purchases at each stop.
The $35-$38 range brings longer walking or hiking tours, all with perfect 5-star ratings. These include all admission fees, and the hiking tour provides water, trekking poles, and park entry. Guests consistently praise the guides’ knowledge and preparation.
Food and drink experiences are the highest-priced, but also the most praised. The Guided 3-Hour Old Town Food Tour at $64 includes generous tastings at 4-5 restaurants and is repeatedly called out for the quality and quantity of food. The Dinner Detective show at $67 includes a multi-course dinner and interactive entertainment, but a handful of reviews complain about poor acting or event organization. The $97 brewery safari includes drinks and a full meal, making it a better value than cheaper tours that do not include food or drinks.
Overall, the best value comes from tours that include all fees, tastings, or meals. Self-guided games can disappoint if support is lacking. Walking and food tours with strong local guides consistently deliver the best experiences.